A New ‘Fantasticks’: Trying to Remember

:

I have great affection for The Fantasticks. The musical’s original-cast album was one of the first I ever owned — and listened to so often that I can still recite most of the lyrics. The show, which opened in 1960 at the little Sullivan Street Playhouse in Greenwich Village (and ran there for 42 years, an all-time record for an American theater production), was the first show I saw when I moved to New York (only a block away from the theater!) in the 1970s.

It’s easy to forget how innovative the show once was. In an era of splashy Broadway musicals with realistic (if romanticized) settings and characters — rival gangs on the west side of Manhattan, a band salesman in turn-of-the-century Iowa, a family singing troupe in Nazi-era Austria — The Fantasticks was an allegorical fable, removed from specific time and place, with generic characters (a boy, a girl, their meddling fathers) enacting a parable of innocence fostered, then lost, and finally regained. There were minimal sets, an onstage narrator — a dashing, vaguely menacing ringmaster called El Gallo — and even a mime, who, among other duties, plays the wall that the fathers have erected between their two houses, to prevent — but secretly encourage — a romance between their children.

The musical’s reputation, alas, has faded; revivals have been rare, and rarely successful. Stephen Sondheim derided the show as the very definition of “twee.” “The time for this kind of faux-naif, sub-Commedia dell-Arte diversion has passed,” pronounced The Guardian’s Michael Billington, reviewing a short-lived West End production in 2010. Well, even my favorite London critic can sometimes be wrong.

The show’s stage innovations are now old hat, and its fairy-tale preciousness decidedly out of vogue. But the real problem in reviving the show, undoubtedly, is the rape scene.  Not a rape, literally, but a faux-abduction, orchestrated by the couple’s fathers, with the help of two hammy, over-the-hill actors, so that the boy can rescue the girl and cement their romance. The lyrics — “So you see the sort of rape/ depends on what you pay” — were jarring enough back then. Today they are unconscionable.

The new Broadway revival solves the lyric problem fairly easily — eliminating the offensive word without disrupting the meter (“So you see the masquerade/ depends on what you pay”). More substantively, it has tried updating the show with some major gender switching. The boy and girl have now become two boys, and the scheming parents cheering on the gay romance are their mothers, not fathers.

Well, if that’s what it takes to get The Fantasticks to Broadway, I’ll buy it. Director and choreographer Christopher Gattelli (who helmed last season’s Tony winner, Schmigadoon!) has remained faithful to the show’s romantic vibe, minimalist esthetic (the grandest stage effect is the mime tossing confetti), and, most important, the wonderful Tom Jones and Harvey Schmidt score.

It is one of the glories of the American musical theater. The show’s best-known song, “Try to Remember,” is the perfect framing device for this delicately didactic tale, with its gentle, waltz-time melody and piquant lyrics (“Without a hurt/ the heart is hollow”). The rest of the score is a nonstop parade of gems, from the comic duets between the two meddling parents (“Plant a Radish”), to the discordant strains that signal the shattering of the first act’s happy ending (“This Plum Is Too Ripe”), to sweet and simple love songs like “They Were You.”

The cast is capable, the staging deft — and yet the revival doesn’t entirely work. The gay romance (I hope I can be excused for pointing this out) doesn’t exactly jibe with the show’s fairy-tale machinations: the fake abduction, which leads the boy to rescue his damsel in distress, lands a little oddly when the damsel is a guy. And the sequence in which El Gallo (Zane Phillips, whose biceps nearly steal the show) introduces one of the lovers to the world’s cruelty and corruption, strikes a discordant note in our present, cruel and corrupt moment. (My theater companion whispered, “Jeffrey Epstein!”).

No, The Fantasticks can’t quite recapture the innocence it once had. But this long-overdue revival at least helps us remember.

2 thoughts on “A New ‘Fantasticks’: Trying to Remember”

  1. Felt the same — and so did my companion, who happens to be gay. As you said, it’s a fable, and they’re both being gay hurts the universality. Plus, I missed a soprano voice in the (still) beautiful, touching score. Also felt the mime was a little too visible, too attention-grabbing, deflecting the role of El Gallo.

    Like

Leave a Reply